The Generals We Made: A Tale of Rank and Revolution


 

“Strange, a country without an army,” Oerip Soemohardjo muttered, the words hanging in the humid air like a death sentence. The taste of unease coated his tongue as he sat in his KNIL uniform, the fabric suddenly feeling foreign against his skin. His mind churned with the impossible contradiction—how in God’s name could a nation declare independence without men ready to bleed for it?

The year was 1945, and Indonesia was a newborn baby screaming in a hospital where all the doctors had fled. Oerip knew—hell, even the lizards clinging to the ceiling knew—there were at least two damned good reasons they needed a military, and they needed it yesterday.

First off, the wolves were circling. Not one pack, but three: Japanese soldiers with nowhere to go but still armed to the teeth; NICA troops riding the coattails of Allied forces, their Dutch commanders licking their chops at the thought of reclaiming their colonial prize; and worst of all, the cancer of internal conflict spreading through the nation’s vital organs.

Second, Christ, the militias. They were everywhere, like ants at a summer picnic. Local boys with homemade weapons and store-bought courage, fighting without strategy, without command, without hope. These ragtag bands were like loaded guns in the hands of toddlers—dangerous to everyone, especially themselves.

On October 5, 1945, Sukarno’s voice crackled through radio speakers across the newborn nation. The proclamation came not with thunder, but with the desperate pragmatism of a man who knew the house was burning: “To strengthen public confidence, the People’s Security Army (TKR) is established.”

Oerip Soemohardjo found himself Chief of Staff of this infant army. It was like being handed the keys to a car still rolling off the assembly line, missing half its parts, with the dealership on fire.

* * *

Remember the ‘80s flick Naga Bonar? Sure you do. That pickpocket from Medan who woke up one morning and decided, what the hell, I’m a general now? He wasn’t alone in that particular brand of madness.

Picture the scene: Naga Bonar and his boys sitting around, divvying up military ranks like Halloween candy. Murad gets colonel. Barjo gets lieutenant colonel. Lukman gets major. Then there’s poor Bujang, standing in the corner, hat in hand.

“What about Bujang?” someone asks.

Lukman snorts. “He carries chairs and tends the horse. Make him a corporal.”

But Naga Bonar—even thieves have their loyalties—won’t hear of it. “How about sergeant?”

Lukman’s face darkens. “Nowhere in the history of any military in the world has anyone been promoted twice in five minutes.”

Oh, but this wasn’t Hollywood fantasy. This was Indonesia in the throes of revolution, where reality often made fiction look reasonable by comparison.

* * *

The real-life Naga Bonar was a jengkol and vegetable peddler named Timur Pane. Before independence turned the world upside down, he’d been picking pockets at Pasar Sambu in Medan, just another street tough with quick fingers and quicker lies.

When independence came, Pane found his true calling in chaos. He gathered around him the worst elements of society—thieves, con men, thugs—and called it the Flying State Militia. Later, he’d upgrade this merry band of miscreants to the Marsose Brigade. And himself? Why, Major General Timur Pane, of course.

The man had the audacity of a demon at Sunday service. He strutted around in a uniform heavy with imaginary honors, extorting a cool ƒ120 million per month from Governor S.M. Amin. His threat was simple and direct: pay up, or I’ll paint the streets red.

Major General Suhardjo Hardjowardjojo—a man with a legitimate claim to his rank—watched this circus with mounting fury. But Pane was unmovable, clutching his self-bestowed rank like a child with a stolen toy.

They finally lured him with the oldest bait in the book—legitimacy. Integrate his “brigade” into the real army, they said. Command the Sumatra Command’s Assault Legion, they promised.

Then came July 27, 1947. The Dutch came ashore at Pantai Cermin with 500 men, their boots heavy on Indonesian soil. Mohammad Hatta called upon Timur Pane’s legion to hold the line at Lubukpakam.

Remember how Pane had boasted he could reclaim Medan from the Dutch in 24 hours? When the moment of truth arrived, his troops scattered like roaches when the kitchen light flicks on.

By 1948, when Hatta introduced the Reorganization and Rationalization policy, Pane’s paper empire crumbled. His precious rank, his identity, his power—all stripped away like bark from a dead tree.

* * *

A.H. Nasution, writing years later, would reveal the twisted truth of those early days. This newborn nation, still wet behind the ears, somehow had to sustain more than half a million soldiers and militias. Among them, sixty men who called themselves “general.”

Sixty generals. In any other context, it would be a punchline.

The explosion of brass wasn’t just ego run amok—though God knows there was plenty of that. It was the inevitable result of a system with no system, where power grew from the barrel of a gun and whoever commanded the most men made the rules.

Nasution told a story once, the kind that makes you laugh until you realize it’s not funny at all. A sergeant major—just imagine some sweaty, overweight middle-aged man with bad teeth and worse ambition—“donated” a few car tires to a general. Tires were gold in those days, black rubber more valuable than black gold.

In the blink of an eye, that sergeant major leapfrogged up the chain of command. No tests. No training. No time served. Just the miraculous alchemy of rubber into rank.

Compare that to the KNIL, where officers spent decades climbing the ladder. Twenty years to make major. Twelve years to make captain. Seven to ten years just to pin on the single bar of a first lieutenant.

The contrast was stark as a lightning flash against midnight: on one side, a colonial military where rank was earned through years of service and oceans of sweat; on the other, a revolutionary army where rank could be claimed, bestowed, or purchased like produce at a market stall.

Was it any wonder the early TKR resembled a house of cards in a hurricane?

And yet, somehow, against all odds and logic, this imperfect, improvised army would eventually coalesce into something real. The chaos would find order. The pretenders would fall away. The true warriors would emerge.

But that’s another story, for another dark night.

Comments