Empty Plots (A Tale of False Saints and Real Fears)


 

You want to hear something that’ll keep you up at night? Something that’ll make you question every historical marker, every roadside memorial, every ancient tombstone you pass on your Sunday drives through the backroads of America? Let me tell you about what happened to me that scorching afternoon in West Java, when I learned that sometimes the dead aren’t where we think they are. And sometimes—here’s the real kicker, friend—they aren’t there at all.

I was with a group of pilgrims, regular folks like you’d see at any church social, heading to the burial site of someone called Mbah Panjalu. The sun beat down like God’s own spotlight, the kind that makes you feel like an ant under a magnifying glass. We had to take a motorboat across something called Situ Lengkong to reach Nusa Gede Island. “Sixteen hectares of holy ground,” they said. “The final resting place of some big shot who brought Islam to these parts.”

(You believe that? Keep reading.)

The boat ride took maybe twenty minutes, tops. Not long enough for what was coming, looking back on it now. When we reached the island, there was this archway—you know the type, meant to make you feel like you’re entering somewhere important. We trudged up what felt like a million steps, surrounded by trees thick with bats. The kind of bats that hang there watching you, their little eyes following your every move like nature’s security cameras.

The weird thing was, despite the heat that had us all sweating through our caps and headscarves, there was this… coolness. Not the good kind, either. The kind that makes the hair on the back of your neck stand up, like someone just walked over your grave.

(Funny choice of words, wouldn’t you say?)

Then we met the caretaker—the kuncen, they called him. He stood there with his back to the tomb, and I swear to God, something about the way he moved wasn’t quite right. You ever see those nature documentaries where they show a praying mantis, how it turns its head? That’s how this guy moved.

“What brings you here, really?” he asked, and his voice had that sing-song quality that makes your stomach drop. “What’s the purpose of this visit?”

Someone from our group—I don’t remember who, and maybe that’s for the best—mumbled something about seeking blessings and peace. The caretaker smiled then, and Jesus Christ, I wish he hadn’t. He started listing off all the reasons people usually came: wealth, fancy cars, better jobs, finding love. The way he said it, though… like he was taking orders at some drive-thru window to hell.

The burial site was quiet. Too quiet. You know what I mean? Earlier, the boats had been packed like sardine cans, but up here? Just a handful of people sitting cross-legged, muttering prayers into the heavy air. We did our own prayers—tawasul and tahlil, they called them—and right then, this breeze kicked up. Not the refreshing kind, mind you. The kind that carries whispers.

Here’s where it gets good.

When we got back to the mainland, comparing notes over our packed lunches like kids after a field trip, we figured out something that turned my blood to ice water: we’d been at the wrong tomb. Not Mbah Panjalu’s at all. Someone—the guide, the boat driver, who knows—had taken us to… somewhere else.

(And wasn’t that caretaker awful interested in what we wanted? In all those material things people pray for?)

You want to know the really scary part? This stuff happens all over Indonesia. They’re calling them fake tombs now, empty graves built to look like the real deal. Some folks create them to make a quick buck off tourists, others to honor made-up ancestors. Hell, back in ancient Egypt, they built fake tombs to throw off grave robbers—imagine that job interview.

Just this past August—and I know this because I’ve been obsessing over it ever since my little adventure—they tore down forty-one fake sacred graves in Sukabumi. Forty-one! Think about that number for a minute. They even arrested some poor bastard with the initial J, had to protect him from the angry mob. Turns out he just wanted to lease the land, but things have a way of getting out of hand, don’t they?

It goes deeper than that, though. In Jerusalem, they’re building fake graves around Al-Aqsa Mosque—hundreds of them—to prove some historical point. Even President Suharto got in on the action back in the day, constructing this elaborate fake burial site for someone called Raden Wijaya and his whole court.

The worst part? These fake tombs, they’re not just empty holes in the ground. They’re gorgeous—intricate carvings, grand structures, the works. Makes the real graves look like someone’s backyard pet cemetery. They put all this effort into the lie, you see. Make it pretty enough, and people will believe anything.

(That’s what keeps me up at night, if you want to know the truth.)

Because here’s the thing: every time someone kneels down to pray at one of these fake graves, every time they leave an offering or whisper their deepest wishes to these empty holes in the ground, they’re feeding something. Not the dead—there’s nobody home in these fancy mausoleums. No, they’re feeding the lie itself, making it stronger, more real.

You think I’m exaggerating? Let me tell you what Professor Ayatrohaedi said—and I looked this up after my little adventure, believe you me? He said these fake parts need to be torn down because they “violate archaeological principles and could mislead public understanding.” That’s academic speak for “we’re letting the darkness in, folks, and it’s wearing a mighty convincing disguise.”

So next time you’re visiting some ancient burial ground, some holy site where miracles supposedly happen, ask yourself: What’s really under that elaborately carved headstone? Who’s really listening to those prayers? And that caretaker with the too-wide smile who’s so interested in what you’re wishing for…

Well, maybe some questions are better left unanswered.

(But you’ll think about it, won’t you? Every time you pass a graveyard, every time you see a historical marker on some lonely road. You’ll wonder what’s really there. And that, dear reader, is the scariest part of all.)

Comments